Columbus Crew SC are the reigning MLS champions. Merchandise sales are skyrocketing. Season ticket sales for a new stadium due to open in July are strong. The fan base is as loyal as it gets. So, don't mess with a good thing, right? Wrong, according to the club's ownership. It decided that now is a perfect time for a major rebranding effort.
Last week, this new visual and verbal brand identity was unveiled. And fans are beyond furious.
In our opinion, the owners made three major mis-steps in this rebranding effort...
STEP 1: INGORE FAN INPUT
Prior to the rebranding effort, the team consulted with its Supporters Group, the Nordecke, about its plans. The fan club urged ownership to not make any changes. But it did anyway. Not only did the team not listen to its fans, it apparently lied to them. Here is what one fan club member said, "They are stripping our club of our history! Our owners lied to us. Last year in January, 2020 they said they would not rebrand us. They said the name, colors, and logo stay. They also said our supporters would have a say in major club changes after WE (the fans) saved our team from relocating! Why are the owners turning their backs on us? Why aren’t they listening? This is an outrage!"
When rebranding, we recommend that you should not only create with your end-users in mind, you should create with your end-users. Then when you launch the new brand, it’s not just you launching it. It's everybody launching it. Everyone feels like they are a part of it.
STEP 2: LOSE THE NAME FANS LOVE
The short-hand name for the team is "The Crew." That is the simple way in which every fan references the club in every situation. It's easy to say and remember. And it means something. It speaks to the work ethic, determination, and mindset of the blue collar Ohioans who helped the team build a strong fan base.
Despite the fans' love for this moniker, the rebranding effort removed it from the club's official name. According to general manager Tim Bezbatchenko, there was an apparent need to increase the emphasis of the city in the name. Fans don't seem to agree.
STEP 3: CREATE VISUALS THAT COMMUNICATE NOTHING
The previous logo contained several thoughtfully designed visual cues that meant something meaningful to fans. This includes the "96," which references the year Major League Soccer and Columbus Crew SC were founded. The Crew were one of 10 inaugural MLS franchises. The nine yellow and black stripes represent the others. This is a significant source of pride for fans.
The rebranding removed all of the historic look & feel of the brand. In its place, the new logo emphasizes a capital "C," which many fans think looks more like a "G" ("go Grew!"). The "C" is encapsulated in a holding shape that mirrors the Ohio flag. In our opinion, this is a very odd design choice. How many people would make that connection? And would it matter if they did? We're skeptical. It's the city's team, not the state's.
Under the "C" on the right side is a triangular shape that seems to have no purpose other than to fill in what would otherwise have been an empty space. That is not a good enough reason, as far as we are concerned.
Rebranding efforts are always a bit controversial. Change is hard. But sometimes it is necessary. In this case, it did not seem to be.
If you think it might be time to undergo a rebranding effort for your company or organization, consult with your fans. Listen to what they have to say. And don't ignore what you hear.
These are my thoughts on how businesses and organizations can create stronger marketing connections with their target audiences. I would love to hear yours.
Thanks for reading.
p.s. If you'd like to connect more strongly with your target audience, I'd love to help. Please message me at Todd@LINKTrainingAndConsulting.com, or call me at (513) 240-8383.
********************************
May 17th update:
The Columbus Crew and its Supporters Group, the Nordecke, issued a
joint statement indicating that the unpopular rebranding decisions will be reversed.