"Even the greatest of legacies evolve or fade."
This insightful line comes from the press release announcing the re-branding of Washington's NFL franchise. For the past two years, it was leveraging "The Washington Football Team" as its interim brand identity. The team scrapped its previous identity—the Washington Redskins, with an 87-year legacy—after years of pressure due to its racist connotations against Native Americans. For the longest time, the team's owner (Daniel Snyder) refused to give in to the pressure. "We'll never change the name," he insisted to USA Today in 2013. "It's that simple. NEVER—you can use caps."
Thankfully, the team finally decided to do what was right. And they did it well. Repositioning a legacy brand with fiercely loyal fans is extremely difficult. But when warranted—as in the case of the Redskins—the initiative needs to be handled decisively. As with any strategy, brand strategy involves choices (and associated sacrifices). When it comes re-building a brand—as with building a brand in the first place—three key choices need to be made.
1) WHO is your target audience?
A brand is not created in a vacuum. It needs to be created in the context of what will resonate with the intended target audience. So, to whatever degree you have the resources (time and budget), get to know as much as you can about your WHO. And involve them in the process of repositioning your brand. The more skin in the game they have, the more ownership they will assume.
Washington took a few years to get it right. This included many months of research, focus groups with fans (the key target audience), and the open solicitation of fan submissions. Compare and contrast this to the disastrous rebranding effort initiated by MLS's Columbus Crew in May 2021. The team rushed the process, ignored their fans, and generated tremendous resentment.
2) WHAT do you stand for?
If you try to be all things to all people, you end up being nothing to no one. Your brand must stand for something. Something that is distinct from your competition and compelling to your target. And there must be obvious reasons to believe this unique stance.
In its re-branding effort, Washington looked to its location and community for inspiration. It sought an identity that embodied the values of service and leadership that define the DMV (the District, Maryland, and Virginia).The choice of "Commanders" delivers beautifully. It elicits the idea of "Commander-in-Chief," a relevant reference that everyone understands. A commander is the commissioned officer in charge of a military unity. So the term appropriately conjures images of battle-tested leaders, unified goals, and a singular mission of winning the war. Given its location in the nation's capital, the team has a clear set of believable reasons to adopt and own this brand position.
3) HOW do you bring the brand to life?
When re-branding a beloved legacy brand, the key is to keep what works and kill what doesn't. It is not an all-or-nothing proposition. If you strip away everything, you will render your brand unfamiliar to your fans.
With respect to Washington, the name "Redskins" had to go. No question. That was the impetus for the re-branding effort. But the team did a great job maintaining other key elements of the brand that had nothing to do with the controversy. The distinct colors will remain burgundy and gold. This color palette is a key piece of equity for the brand.
Washington took command of its brand. They did what was right, and they did it well. You can, too. Just focus on WHO, WHAT, and HOW.
These are my thoughts on how businesses and organizations can reposition their brands to create stronger marketing connections with their target audiences. I would love to hear yours.
Thanks for reading.
p.s. If you'd like to connect more strongly with your target audience, I'd love to help. Please message me at Todd@LINKTrainingAndConsulting.com, or call me at (513) 240-8383.